A fellow Substacker, Vinay Prasad, has just revealed that one of his recent posts was written by the new Artificial Intelligence gizmo, ChatGPT. One itty-bitty problem: Prasad, whose ‘Stack called the shot early on the Covid hysteria, hadn’t told his readers that what they were reading was written by a robot.
He apologized today, sorta.
The essay generated lots of comments, and no one thought that I didn't write it.
What's the lesson: software like chat GPT and Bard have made remarkable progress. At this pace, they will soon become indistinguishable from the people they emulate. Look how close we are already.
Which, depending on your point of view is either scary as hell (reader’s perspective) or a wonderful labor multiplier (publisher’s view). Media has been freaking out; Elon Musk says it will destroy humanity; TV and movie writers are on strike to keep this AI thingy at bay (not to worry, since no entertainment exec will get software onto a casting couch).
But surely, the robot wouldn’t be able to cope with this instruction: Write a 1000-word essay in the style of the Substack "Portland Dissent" by Richard Cheverton.
I mean, how freaking obscure can you be?
Well…judge for yourselves…
The Shifting Winds of Dissent: A Reflection on Portland's Vibrant Activist Spirit
In the vibrant city of Portland, Oregon, a hotbed of progressive ideals and countercultural movements, dissent has become a way of life. From the iconic protests against systemic injustice to the grassroots initiatives for environmental sustainability, Portland has earned a reputation as a hub for activism. In this essay, we will explore the multifaceted nature of dissent in Portland, delving into its historical roots, examining its present-day manifestations, and contemplating its potential future trajectory. By channeling the spirit of Richard Cheverton, the renowned Substack writer of "Portland Dissent," we aim to capture the essence of Portland's unique activist culture.
Historical Roots of Dissent:
Portland's rich history of dissent stretches back decades, with the city having played a pivotal role in various social justice movements. From the civil rights era to the anti-war protests of the 1960s, Portland's activists have continuously challenged the status quo. The city's progressive spirit is deeply intertwined with its culture, attracting individuals who reject complacency and yearn for change. The struggle for racial equality, LGBTQ+ rights, and gender equality has always been at the forefront of Portland's dissenting narrative.
Present-Day Manifestations:
In the present day, Portland remains a hotbed of activism, with dissent permeating every aspect of public life. Protests, marches, and demonstrations have become common occurrences, often centered around issues such as police brutality, income inequality, and climate change. The Black Lives Matter movement, sparked by the tragic death of George Floyd, found fertile ground in Portland, leading to months of sustained protests. Activists are tireless in their efforts to amplify marginalized voices, challenge oppressive systems, and foster a more inclusive society.
The unique blend of art and activism is a defining characteristic of Portland's dissent. Graffiti adorns the city's walls, serving as a visual testament to the indomitable spirit of resistance. Public art installations offer poignant social commentaries, provoking thought and stimulating conversations. Music, poetry, and theater serve as powerful mediums for dissent, allowing artists to express their discontent and inspire change. From the local indie band playing at a grassroots fundraiser to the street performers advocating for social justice, Portland's creative community thrives on the synergy between art and activism.
Challenges and Controversies:
However, dissent in Portland is not without its challenges and controversies. The city's reputation for violent clashes between protesters and law enforcement has garnered national attention. The actions of a few have overshadowed the peaceful intentions of many, leading to debates about the efficacy of certain tactics and the potential for escalation. Moreover, there are concerns that the diverse range of causes and ideologies within Portland's activist community can sometimes lead to fragmentation, diluting the impact of collective efforts. Building bridges and finding common ground is crucial for sustaining a united front against injustice.
The Future of Portland's Dissent:
As we look to the future, it is essential to consider the trajectory of dissent in Portland. The city's activist spirit has the potential to fuel lasting change, provided it can adapt and evolve. A key challenge lies in the ability to translate the energy and passion of protests into tangible policy reforms. Effective grassroots organizing, strategic alliances, and targeted political engagement can amplify the voices of the marginalized and compel decision-makers to act. By harnessing the power of social media and innovative communication platforms, Portland's dissenters can extend their reach and mobilize broader support for their causes.
Additionally, fostering dialogue and understanding among diverse perspectives will be crucial in maintaining a cohesive movement. Embracing inclusivity and empathy while navigating the complexities of intersectionality will strengthen the foundations of dissent in Portland. By recognizing the interconnections between various social justice issues, activists can forge powerful coalitions capable of addressing systemic inequalities holistically.
Conclusion:
Portland's dissent is a dynamic force, shaped by the city's history, the passions of its residents, and the challenges it faces. It is an amalgamation of courage, creativity, and conviction that refuses to accept the status quo. While dissent in Portland may face obstacles and controversies, its potential for effecting meaningful change is undeniable. As Richard Cheverton would likely argue in "Portland Dissent," it is through the collective efforts of activists, the resilience of marginalized communities, and the dedication to a more just and equitable society that the winds of dissent in Portland will continue to blow, shaping the city's future and inspiring others across the nation.
Well, at least the robot got the “renowned” part right…
I Quit
"not to worry, since no entertainment exec will get software onto a casting couch" This is why AI will never replace you. Still laughing days after first reading this.
The essay… nauseating. You’d never say those things. Jeez, it sounded like something you’d hear any garden variety PSU professor put down. Predictable…